Fr Josiah Trenham on Eastern Orthodox Theology, Catholicism, and the Reformation

Introduction

This tutorial explores the key themes and insights shared by Fr. Josiah Trenham regarding Eastern Orthodox theology, Catholicism, and the Reformation. By breaking down the main points from his discussion, you will gain a deeper understanding of the differences between these faith traditions, as well as the potential for unity among them. Whether you are exploring Orthodoxy, Catholicism, or Protestantism, this guide provides a structured overview of the conversation.

Step 1: Understand Fr. Josiah's Conversion to Orthodoxy

Fr. Josiah Trenham shares his personal journey of converting to the Orthodox Church. Key points to consider include:

• Personal Experience: Reflect on the transformative experiences that led him to choose Orthodoxy.
• Faith Fulfillment: Explore the aspects of Orthodox faith that he found lacking in Protestantism and Catholicism.

Step 2: Critique of Catholicism

Fr. Josiah discusses several challenges within Catholicism, focusing on:

• Gap Between Teaching and Practice: Recognize the discrepancies between official Catholic doctrines and the average believer's practice.
• Papal Infallibility: Understand the criticisms surrounding the doctrine of papal infallibility and its implications for the Church.

Step 3: The Need for Reunification

The conversation highlights the potential for unity between Eastern Orthodoxy and Catholicism:

• Common Grounds: Identify shared beliefs that could serve as a foundation for dialogue.
• Challenges to Unity: Acknowledge the theological and historical obstacles that hinder reunification.

Step 4: Evaluate the Reformation

Fr. Josiah offers a nuanced appraisal of the Reformation:

• Pros and Cons: List the positive outcomes of the Reformation, such as increased scriptural accessibility, alongside its challenges, particularly the fragmentation of Christian unity.
• Heresy of Sola Scriptura: Discuss his perspective on "sola scriptura" and how it contrasts with Orthodox views on Scripture and Tradition.

Step 5: Explore Orthodox Views on Scripture and Tradition

Key to understanding Orthodoxy is its approach to Scripture and Tradition:

• Role of Tradition: Examine how Tradition complements Scripture in Orthodox theology.
• Interconnectedness: Learn about the relationship between Scripture interpretation and the teachings of the Church Fathers.

Step 6: Understand Salvation in Orthodoxy

Fr. Josiah presents an Orthodox perspective on salvation:

• Process of Salvation: Understand salvation as a journey rather than a one-time event, emphasizing the role of faith and works.
• Theosis: Familiarize yourself with the concept of theosis, or becoming one with God's divine nature.

Conclusion

Fr. Josiah Trenham's insights provide a rich understanding of Eastern Orthodox theology in relation to Catholicism and Protestantism. By reflecting on his conversion story, critiques of Catholicism, and assessments of the Reformation, you can appreciate the complexities and nuances of these faith traditions. Consider exploring further by visiting the resources linked in the video description or engaging with the Orthodox community to deepen your knowledge.