9 Plot Mistakes Every New Fantasy Writer Makes

Introduction

This tutorial highlights the common plot mistakes that new fantasy writers often make, based on insights from the video "9 Plot Mistakes Every New Fantasy Writer Makes" by Jed Herne. Understanding these pitfalls can help you craft a compelling story and avoid common errors that could weaken your narrative.

Step 1: Avoid Beating the Antagonist Too Early

• Introduce tension by allowing the conflict between the protagonist and antagonist to develop.
• Ensure that the final confrontation feels earned; don’t resolve major conflicts too quickly.
• Create obstacles that prolong the conflict, maintaining reader engagement.

Step 2: Vary Scene Formats

• Repetitive scene structures can bore readers. Strive for variety in your storytelling.
• Experiment with different perspectives, settings, and tones for each scene.
• Use contrasting scene types to enhance emotional impact and keep the narrative fresh.

Step 3: Develop an Active Protagonist

• Ensure your protagonist is driving the action rather than being passive.
• Have them make decisions that affect the plot and face the consequences of those choices.
• Create scenarios where the protagonist must take initiative to overcome challenges.

Step 4: Strengthen the Throughline

• A weak throughline can confuse readers about the story’s main focus.
• Establish clear goals for your protagonist and ensure every subplot supports these goals.
• Regularly check that all narrative elements contribute to the overall journey.

Step 5: Avoid the Soggy Middle

• The middle of your story shouldn’t drag; maintain momentum with rising stakes.
• Introduce new challenges or revelations that keep the protagonist’s journey engaging.
• Reassess pacing and consider tools like cliffhangers or subplots to sustain interest.

Step 6: Create Meaningful Consequences

• Ensure that actions have consequences that affect the plot and character development.
• Avoid scenarios where characters can easily escape from difficult situations without repercussions.
• Make it clear how choices impact the story’s direction and the protagonist’s growth.

Step 7: Align the Three Ps

• The three Ps are premise, plot, and character. They should align cohesively.
• Regularly review how your premise informs the plot and character arcs.
• Ensure that character motivations are consistent with the overarching plot and premise.

Step 8: Avoid the Peter-Out Ending

• Your story’s ending should feel satisfying and conclusive, not rushed or unresolved.
• Tie up major plot points and character arcs in a way that feels rewarding.
• Consider leaving some elements open-ended to provoke thought, but avoid ambiguity that frustrates readers.

Step 9: Eliminate Lucky Breaks for the Protagonist

• Avoid relying on coincidences or luck to solve problems for your characters.
• Ensure that the protagonist’s successes come from their abilities and decisions, not chance.
• Develop skills or knowledge in your protagonist that they can use to navigate challenges.

Conclusion

By recognizing and addressing these common plot mistakes, you can enhance the quality of your fantasy writing. Focus on building a strong narrative structure, developing active characters, and ensuring that conflicts and resolutions feel earned. As you refine your story, consider seeking feedback to further improve your craft. Happy writing!