BAHASA INDONESIA KELAS 10 - BAB 2 MENGUNGKAPKAN KRITIK LEWAT SENYUMAN KURIKULUM MERDEKA

Introduction

This tutorial is designed to help you understand how to express criticism through a positive lens, using the concept of "smiling criticism" as introduced in the Indonesian curriculum. This approach not only encourages constructive feedback but also fosters a positive atmosphere in communication.

Step 1: Understanding the Concept of Smiling Criticism

• Definition: Smiling criticism refers to providing feedback or critique in a manner that is gentle and constructive, often accompanied by a positive demeanor.
• Importance: This method helps maintain relationships and encourages receptiveness to feedback.
• Application: Use smiling criticism in everyday situations, such as in school, at work, or in personal relationships.

Step 2: Recognizing the Right Moment for Criticism

• Evaluate the Situation: Consider whether the context is appropriate for delivering criticism.
• Timing: Choose a moment when the recipient is calm and open to discussion.
• Setting: Ensure you are in a private or semi-private environment to avoid embarrassment.

Step 3: Framing Your Critique Positively

• Use Constructive Language: Focus on the behavior or action rather than the person.
  • Example: Instead of saying "You did this wrong," try "I believe this approach could be improved by…"
• Balance Negative and Positive Feedback: Start with a compliment, followed by the critique, and end with encouragement.
  • Structure:
    1. Compliment: "I really like how dedicated you are."
    2. Critique: "However, this part could be clearer."
    3. Encouragement: "I’m sure with a bit more clarity, your work will shine even more!"

Step 4: Practicing Smiling Criticism

• Role-Playing: Engage in role-playing exercises with friends or peers to practice delivering feedback.
• Feedback Sessions: Set up regular feedback sessions where both parties can give and receive criticism in a supportive environment.

Step 5: Reflecting on the Feedback Process

• Self-Assessment: After giving feedback, reflect on how it was received.
• Adjust Approach: If the feedback wasn't well-received, think about how you could adjust your delivery next time.
• Seek Input: Ask for feedback on your feedback style to improve continuously.

Conclusion

Smiling criticism is a vital skill for effective communication, especially within educational and professional settings. By understanding when and how to critique positively, you can enhance relationships and promote a culture of growth. Start practicing these techniques today to become a more effective communicator. Remember, the goal is to support and uplift while providing constructive feedback.